Image source, Ira L. Black / Corbis / MOHD RASFAN / Kristina Solovyova / POOL / AFP via Getty Images

Preparations for the first trilateral meeting of the leaders of China, Russia and America have increased concern in Europe.

On November 4, Russian President Vladimir Putin visited an exhibition at the Manege (Central Exhibition Hall) in Moscow's Red Square. During this time a group of school children was also with him. There he stopped in front of a large statue of the Yalta Conference held in February 1945.

In this statue, the then British Prime Minister Winston Churchill, US President Franklin D Roosevelt and Soviet Union leader Joseph Stalin are shown.

"These were the leaders of the three major powers who came together to discuss what the world order should be like after the war," Putin told the children.

A day before this, China's Foreign Ministry and the Kremlin had announced that talks are going on for a meeting between Putin, US President Donald Trump and China's President Xi Jinping on November 18-19.

The three leaders are going to attend the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in Shenzhen. On Friday, White House spokeswoman Olivia Wells confirmed that the meeting would take place.

When news first broke in October that Russia was proposing such a meeting, there was immediate concern in the EU and Ukraine. Many people remembered this from the meeting held in Yalta in February 1945.

At that time the leaders of the anti-Hitler coalition met in the old house of the Russian Tsar on the banks of the Black Sea. The Soviet Union's expansion of influence in Eastern Europe was accepted in exchange for Stalin's agreement to enter the war against Japan after victory over Germany.

End

Along with this, a secret agreement was made regarding East Asia. Under this, Japan's South Sakhalin and Kuril Islands were given to the Soviet Union.

The Soviet naval base at Port Arthur, China was reinstated and special economic interests in Manchuria were also sanctioned.

Since then, the term 'Yalta' has often been used in Eastern Europe to refer to agreements between major powers that divide the world into spheres of influence without regard to smaller countries.

It also includes the areas of those countries, which big powers decide to divide.

Image source: Getty Images

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky said, "I absolutely do not want this to become Yalta Two, Three or Four, where spheres of influence are simply redistributed."

He said, "After Alaska, if events proceed in the same manner as Russian officials have been signaling their desire for a new 'Yalta', it will be Russia's second major diplomatic victory."

At the same time, German Chancellor Friedrich Merz said that it is necessary to include Europe in any discussion regarding ending the war in Ukraine.

"Europe wants and must play a role in this process," he said.

"The key issues of the peace agreement, whether related to sanctions or the future security arrangement, cannot be resolved without the participation of European countries. All parties know this," he said.

Image source: History/Universal Images Group via Getty Images

Special stories selected for you by Nitin Srivastava

Learn more

However, according to the Wall Street Journal report, Putin's aim may be to gain support on terms favorable to Russia to end the war in Ukraine. But it is not yet clear what issues he actually wants to discuss with Trump and Jinping.

Yuri Ushakov, an aide to the Russian President, said, "The issue of Ukraine will definitely come up for discussion in some form or the other."

However, he said, "At the moment, we only have a preliminary outline of what issues could be discussed at such a high level and in such an unusual format."

Trump has denied that Ukraine is on the agenda of the meeting. He said, "We can meet to discuss nuclear weapons and nuclear disarmament."

According to Joseph Torizian, associate professor at The American University in Washington, China does not want to participate in Ukraine talks in which Europe is kept out. China is making every effort to weaken its image of supporting Russia in the war.

In recent years, influential people in China have given less importance to the European Union than before. However, being major trading partners, China is still interested in maintaining good relations with European countries.

Torizian says that Beijing is also skeptical about talks regarding nuclear weapons.

He said, "China believes that its nuclear program is small and one of its advantages is that not much information about it is made public."

Whose benefit?

Russia's interest in such a meeting is clear. He wants to keep Europe out of the talks on Ukraine and once again show that Moscow cannot be isolated on the international stage.

The attraction of this meeting is clear even for the President of America.

Torizian says, "Trump is excited about this meeting, because it will have grandeur and a special atmosphere."

He said, "He will be able to tell the story of how wonderful it is that the great powers of the world have come together, that he is the first to do so, and that he is bringing peace."

But the benefits of this meeting are not so clear for Beijing. "Yalta is not a good memory for China," says Torizian.

China was angry that Stalin had secured special interests for the Soviet Union in Manchuria.

Torizian says, "After the Communist victory in China in 1949, Mao (Mao Zedong) also realized that what the Soviet Union had demanded at Yalta and the demands it continued to make after that, were a big deal for China."

These disputes were also one of the reasons for the later differences between China and the Soviet Union.

In the case of Eastern Europe, historians still debate whether the Soviet Union took advantage of the situation at that time.

By February 1945, Soviet forces had already captured Romania, Bulgaria and large parts of Poland, Hungary and Czechoslovakia.

But today the Russian army does not even control the entire area of ​​eastern Ukraine, which the Kremlin has already declared as part of Russia. Moreover, unlike in 1945, only one of the countries expected to attend the summit is directly involved in the war.

international reputation

Torizian says Russia is the only country still interested in dividing the world clearly into spheres of influence.

In the national security strategy adopted by the Trump administration, the Western world has been described as America's sphere of influence. Despite this, America is not giving up its support to Taiwan. At the same time, China's presence in Latin America is still important for Beijing.

Marcin Kachmarski of Glasgow University says that Russia considers itself a superpower equal to America and China. China's official statements also often give equal status to Russia. But behind closed doors, neither Chinese experts nor China's leadership consider Russia an equal power.

He said, "China's leadership and influential people there consider only America equal to China."

Kachmarski says that such a trilateral summit can increase Beijing's prestige at the international level. This will project Jinping's image as a global leader whom heads of other major powers travel to meet.

Image source: AFP

But after the defeat of the Republican Party in the midterm elections of the US Congress, Trump's position on the global stage has become less strong than before.

Kachmarski says the question is whether China wants to strengthen their international position. He said, "I am still not completely confident about this meeting."

During his visits to Eastern Europe in the 2000s, the then US President George W Bush had several times described the Yalta Agreements as a historical evil.

According to the New York Times, his comments were specifically for Putin. Bush told him that Russia had no right to interfere in the affairs of its neighboring countries and that it should apologize for the actions of the Soviet Union.

In 2002, in Vilnius, the capital of Lithuania, Bush said, "No more Yalta."

If after almost 25 years Putin succeeds in holding a meeting with the leaders of America and China, which is even to some extent similar to the Yalta conference, then it will be a small victory for him. Even if no concrete results come from this meeting.

We used AI to translate this article, which was originally written in English. A BBC journalist checked this translation before publication. Learn more about how we're using AI.

Published by Collective Newsroom for the BBC.

Download the new BBC World Service app

Choose BBC News Hindi and get news alerts, live TV, podcasts... all in one place

Please note: The new app is not available in the UK and US.

short video

end of short video

top story

When Trump, Putin and Jinping meet: What impact will the historic meeting have on the world?

Live, tension increases between Saudi Arabia and Houthis, claim of attack on airport in Riyadh

Akhilesh Yadav busy in garnering Dalit votes before UP elections, gave this political message from Agra

must read

most popular